Guaranteed Returns Are Not an EB-5 Feature. They Are a Denial.

An EB-5 investment must be genuinely at risk. Redemption rights, debt arrangements, and guaranteed buybacks have disqualified investors for nearly three decades, and the statute now says so directly.

Topic page: EB-5

GuidePrivate Client6 min readPublished Updated
Lidice Samper, Esq.
Lidice Samper, Esq. in collaboration with Kloss Martino
Founder & Managing Attorney
All Insights by Lidice Samper
Accurate as of

Every EB-5 investor wants to protect their capital, and every sponsor wants to make the offering attractive. That shared interest produces the most persistent structural error in the program: terms that make the investment feel safe also make it ineligible.

The rule

An EB-5 investor must place capital "at risk for the purpose of generating a return." 8 CFR 204.6(j)(2). The statute, as amended by the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022, now spells out what does not count. Capital does not include funds "invested in exchange for a note, bond, convertible debt, obligation, or any other debt arrangement between the alien investor and the new commercial enterprise," and does not include capital subject to an agreement giving the investor "a contractual right to repayment." 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(5)(D)(ii)(III).

That codifies what USCIS has applied since 1998, when a set of precedent decisions established the modern framework:

  • Matter of Izummi, 22 I&N Dec. 169 (Assoc. Comm'r 1998), held that an investor's right to sell their interest back at a guaranteed price, and similar redemption arrangements, turn equity into debt and defeat the at-risk requirement.
  • Matter of Soffici, 22 I&N Dec. 158 (Assoc. Comm'r 1998), addressed how assets and money are valued and traced into the enterprise.
  • Matter of Ho, 22 I&N Dec. 206 (Assoc. Comm'r 1998), held that capital is not at risk merely because it has been placed in a business; the business plan must show actual undertaking of business activity.

Structures that fail

Guaranteed buybacks or put options. Any right to require the enterprise, the regional center, or an affiliate to repurchase the investor's interest at a fixed or minimum price is a contractual right to repayment. The statute distinguishes a buyback option exercisable solely at the enterprise's discretion, which can be allowed. The deal documents decide which one you have.

Promissory notes to the investor. If the investor lends money to the new commercial enterprise and receives a note, the investment is debt. This is different from the common and permissible structure in which the enterprise, after receiving equity from investors, makes a loan to a separate job-creating entity.

Guaranteed returns. A promised fixed return, regardless of project performance, signals that the investor bears no real loss exposure.

Side letters. Undisclosed agreements that override the offering documents are treated as part of the investment. A clean limited partnership agreement does not survive a side letter promising repayment.

Structures that can work

Escrow pending approval. Funds placed in escrow and released to the enterprise upon petition approval, with a refund if the petition is denied, has long been accepted when the escrow terms are properly drafted, because the refund is conditioned on an immigration outcome rather than on the investment's performance.

Equity in a lending enterprise. The typical regional center model: investors take equity in a new commercial enterprise, which lends to a project company. The investor's return depends on the loan being repaid, which depends on the project.

Loans to the investor. Loan proceeds the investor borrows and then invests as equity can qualify as the investor's own capital, a position confirmed in Zhang v. USCIS, No. 19-5021 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 27, 2020). The borrowing must be in good faith and not a means of circumventing the rules on permissible capital. 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(5)(L)(iii)(I).

Planned exit after the sustainment period. The statute requires the capital to be expected to remain invested for not less than two years. 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(5)(A)(i). An exit plan that depends on project performance, such as refinancing or sale, is not a guarantee. A fixed repayment date disconnected from how the project performs is closer to a guarantee.

Reading the offering documents like a CFO

The at-risk question is decided in the documents, not in the sales presentation. When we review an offering, the financial questions we ask are:

  • Where in the capital stack does the EB-5 money sit, and what is senior to it?
  • What is the source of repayment, and what happens if the senior lender is not repaid first?
  • Is any affiliate of the sponsor providing a completion guarantee, a repayment guarantee, or a purchase commitment? To whom does it run?
  • What does "return of capital" mean in the partnership agreement, and who controls the timing?
  • Are there any other agreements, including marketing agent arrangements, that promise the investor anything?

An offering that answers these questions clearly is not risk-free. It is appropriately risky, which is what the statute requires.

The proposed rule

DHS's July 2, 2026 proposed rule would codify additional capital at-risk standards, including a requirement to show concrete business activity. 91 FR 40676. It remains a proposal, and existing statutory and precedent requirements apply today.

Frequently asked questions

Reviewed November 12, 2026

Can an EB-5 investment come with a guaranteed return?

No. EB-5 capital must be at risk for the purpose of generating a return, and a guaranteed rate of return or guaranteed repayment of the invested capital disqualifies it. Ordinary, non-guaranteed distributions and projected returns are permitted.

Can I lend money to the project instead of investing in it for EB-5?

Not as the investor. Capital excludes funds invested in exchange for a note, bond, convertible debt or other debt arrangement between the investor and the new commercial enterprise. The common regional center model, where the enterprise in turn lends pooled capital to a project, is a different structure and is permitted.

Is a buyback or redemption right allowed in an EB-5 deal?

It depends who controls it. An investor's right to require repurchase at a fixed or minimum price is a contractual right to repayment and defeats the at-risk requirement, as Matter of Izummi held in 1998. The statute distinguishes a buyback option exercisable solely at the enterprise's discretion, which can be allowed. The deal documents decide which one you have.

Sources

Lidice Samper, Esq.
Written by
Lidice Samper, Esq.
Founder & Managing Attorney

Founder and Managing Attorney of Samper Law, Lidice leads the firm's uncompromising litigation standards with relentless advocacy and strategic precision honed across federal and state courts.

In collaboration with
Kloss Martino
Business Advisory Collaborator

Kloss Martino is a separate business advisory firm, not a law firm. Its engagements and fees are independent of Samper Law's, and legal advice comes only from Samper Law attorneys.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. Immigration law and agency policy change frequently; the analysis above reflects our understanding as of the date noted. Readers should consult counsel regarding their specific circumstances.

Related in Private Client
UpdatePrivate Client4 min read

CBP One Parolees: If USCIS Denied Your Case After the April 2025 Termination Email, You Can Ask It to Reopen, Free

A Boston federal court ordered relief for people paroled through CBP One whose parole was ended by a mass email in April 2025. USCIS now says class members in Sileiri Doe v. DHS can ask it to reopen or reconsider a denial issued between April 1, 2025 and April 21, 2026, with no filing fee and no deadline. Who qualifies, what is covered, and why waiting is still a mistake.

Prarup Ghimire, Esq.Prarup Ghimire, Esq.Accurate as of November 3, 2026
UpdatePrivate Client5 min read

Election Day Is November 3. For a Green Card Holder, One Ballot Can Cost the Green Card.

On October 19, 2026, federal prosecutors charged 28 California green card holders with voting or registering to vote. Voting as a noncitizen is a federal crime, a ground of removal that requires no conviction, and a common reason naturalization is denied. What permanent residents, and the families of new citizens, should check before November 3.

Prarup Ghimire, Esq.Prarup Ghimire, Esq.Accurate as of October 26, 2026
UpdatePrivate Client6 min read

November 2026 Visa Bulletin: Four Family Categories Jump a Full Year, and USCIS Is Taking Filings on the Earlier Chart

The November 2026 Visa Bulletin moves F1, F2B, F3 and F4 forward by a full year for most countries, advances EB-2 by three months and EB-3 Other Workers by five, and leaves India EB-2, EB-4 and EB-5 where they were. USCIS says every family and employment applicant must use the Dates for Filing chart this month. Who can file now, and why filing is no longer the same as being safe.

Lidice Samper, Esq.Lidice Samper, Esq.Accurate as of October 26, 2026