
Reviewed by Lidice Samper, Esq.
Accurate as of November 11, 2026
Related FAQ: Can the Department of Labor fine an employer without a jury?
When the Department of Labor concludes that an employer of visa workers underpaid them or broke the terms of its program, the case usually never reaches a federal judge. It goes to one of DOL's own administrative law judges, who can order back wages and civil money penalties, with review inside the agency and only limited review in court afterward.
On November 10, 2026, the Supreme Court heard argument on whether that system is constitutional. The case is Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, LLC, No. 25-966.
The case
Sun Valley Orchards is a New Jersey farm that employed seasonal workers through the H-2A agricultural visa program. DOL's Wage and Hour Division found violations ranging from the early termination of workers to kitchen access, beverage sales and undisclosed deductions, transportation and housing. It assessed back wages and civil money penalties that, according to the farm's brief, add up to "over half a million dollars in liability." An administrative law judge largely affirmed the assessments.
The farm went to federal court. The Third Circuit held that the administrative proceeding could not be reconciled with Article III of the Constitution, which reserves the judicial power to federal courts (148 F.4th 121, judgment entered July 29, 2025). The government petitioned, and the Supreme Court granted review on April 27, 2026.
The Court is deciding two questions:
- Whether Article III bars DOL from adjudicating proceedings "to collect monetary remedies from employers who have allegedly violated the terms and conditions of employment of H-2A workers and domestic workers in corresponding employment."
- Whether the H-2A statute, 8 U.S.C. 1188(g)(2), authorizes those proceedings at all.
Why it follows Jarkesy
In SEC v. Jarkesy (2024), the Court held that when the government seeks civil penalties for violations that resemble common law claims, the defendant is entitled to a jury in a federal court, unless the matter falls within the "public rights" exception that lets Congress assign some disputes to agencies. The government's position in Sun Valley is that immigration programs, and the conditions Congress attaches to the privilege of hiring foreign workers, are public rights. The farm's position is that a claim for unpaid wages under an employment contract is the kind of private claim courts have always heard.
Reports of the argument read it differently, and we would not predict the outcome. A decision is expected by the end of the Court's term in late June 2027.
Why H-1B sponsors should care
The case is about H-2A, but the enforcement model is not unique to farms. DOL enforces the obligations in every H-1B Labor Condition Application, including the required wage, notice and benching rules, through the same structure: a Wage and Hour investigation, an administrative law judge, and back wages and civil money penalties under 8 U.S.C. 1182(n) and DOL's regulations at 20 CFR part 655, subpart I. H-2B enforcement works the same way.
A ruling for the farm would give employers a strong argument that penalty claims must be brought in federal court, with a jury. A ruling for DOL would confirm the current system at the moment DOL, under Project Firewall, has begun opening H-1B investigations without waiting for a complaint.
What to do while the Court decides
- Do not plan around a win. Until June, every DOL investigation proceeds under the current rules.
- Keep the public access file complete for every LCA: the certified LCA, wage documentation, the prevailing wage source and proof of notice. It is the file an investigator asks to see.
- Preserve the constitutional objection. If you are already in a DOL proceeding, ask counsel now whether to raise the Article III and Seventh Amendment issues on the record, so the argument is not lost if the Court rules for employers.
- Read the decision with your counsel when it issues. The reasoning, not only the result, will decide how far it reaches beyond H-2A.
If you have received a Wage and Hour letter or an LCA complaint, call Samper Law at (781) 321-3700.
Frequently asked questions
Reviewed November 13, 2026
Can the Department of Labor fine an employer without a jury?
Today, yes: DOL imposes back wages and civil money penalties on H-2A and H-1B employers through its own administrative law judges. The Supreme Court heard a challenge to that system on November 10, 2026 in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, No. 25-966, and a decision is expected by late June 2027.
What should an employer in a DOL proceeding do now?
Keep complying with the current rules, keep every LCA public access file complete, and ask counsel whether to preserve the Article III and Seventh Amendment objections on the record now.
Related analysis
Sources
- Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, LLC, No. 25-966, petition for a writ of certiorari (filed Feb. 12, 2026), certiorari granted Apr. 27, 2026, argued Nov. 10, 2026; Brief of Respondent (July 27, 2026).
- Sun Valley Orchards, LLC v. U.S. Department of Labor, 148 F.4th 121 (3d Cir. 2025).
- SEC v. Jarkesy, 603 U.S. 109 (2024).
- 8 U.S.C. 1188(g)(2); 8 U.S.C. 1182(n); 20 CFR part 655, subpart I.
General information, not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney client relationship.

A former prosecutor and formidable trial attorney, Maeve commands complex federal and state litigation with an insider's mastery of courtroom and prosecutorial strategy.